April 9, 2024

Email Marketing Guide for Recruitment Agencies: Attracting Clients and Candidates

Table of Contents

As a recruitment agency, email marketing allows you to cast a wider net to attract both clients and candidates. Implementing strategies like candidate specs and separate domains for mass outreach protects your main inbox while increasing the number of prospects you reach. This guide will provide actionable tips to grow your business, from properly warming up cold email domains to showcasing candidate profiles that convert potential clients. With dedicated sections on targeting both clients and candidates, you'll learn how to maximize the return from your email campaigns.

Using Email to Attract New Clients

Recruitment agencies can leverage email marketing to connect with potential new clients. By developing a targeted outreach campaign, you can generate interest in your services and win new business.

Crafting an Effective Pitch

Focus your pitch on how you can address the hiring needs and challenges of your target clients. For example, highlight your access to top candidates in niche roles or your success placing candidates who significantly impact revenue and growth. Keep your message brief while conveying your key value propositions.

Building a Targeted List

Identify companies that regularly hire for positions you specialize in filling. Search business directories and social platforms to find key decision makers, like HR managers or executives. Segment your list by company size, industry, location, or other attributes to tailor your messaging.

Warming Up Cold Outreach

When reaching out to new prospects via email, start by "warming up" your contact. Connect with them on LinkedIn and engage with their updates to become familiar. Mention a common connection or recent news about their company in your initial email to personalize your pitch. Keep emails concise but compelling, with a clear call-to-action like requesting a 15-minute call.

With a strategic approach to researching your target clients, crafting a persuasive pitch, and warming up cold outreach, you can make email marketing a powerful tool for attracting new recruitment clients. Consistently refining your messaging and call-to-actions based on response rates will optimize your results over time.

Nurturing Leads With Ongoing Email Campaigns

Securing Candidates

To secure top candidates, send anonymous candidate specifications (specs) to clients describing a candidate’s experience, qualifications, and desired compensation without revealing their identity. Explain that the candidate is interested in new opportunities and gauge the client’s interest level. If positive, set up an interview and work to make a successful placement. Regular candidate specs establish your agency as a go-to resource for quality candidates.

Warming Up Cold Email Campaigns

To reach new clients, set up a separate domain solely for mass email campaigns. Start by sending a small batch of high-quality, customized emails to determine open and response rates. Gradually increase the volume while monitoring metrics to avoid spam filtering. As open and response rates rise, you can shift some recipients to your primary domain. Nurture all responses with follow-up emails and phone calls. Track campaign metrics to refine targeting and messaging.

Maintaining Contact

For existing clients and candidates, send a drip campaign with helpful content, open position listings, candidate recommendations, and company updates. For candidates, highlight new roles that match their experience and career goals. For clients, suggest candidates that fit their hiring needs and company culture. Timely, value-added emails strengthen relationships, encourage repeat business, and generate new opportunities on both sides.

With strategic, multi-channel email marketing focused on the needs of clients and candidates, recruitment agencies can build a robust pipeline of new business. Consistency is key, so ongoing optimization and high-quality, relevant content are musts. Used effectively, email is a cost-efficient tool for lead generation, nurturing relationships, and driving results.

Generating New Client Leads With Candidate Specs

Candidate specs refer to anonymized CVs you send to potential new clients to generate interest in your recruitment services. Sending targeted candidate specs to companies you would like to do business with is an effective way to get your foot in the door and win new clients.

To make the most of candidate specs, focus on matching candidates to job openings you know clients have. Pay attention to skills, experience, qualifications, and other attributes the client values based on job ads and their company culture. Only send candidate details that are directly relevant to the position. Keep the information concise while highlighting why the candidate would be an excellent fit.

Build Rapport and Trust

Sending unsolicited candidate details to new clients requires a thoughtful approach. Do some research on the key decision makers and personalize your outreach. Explain your recruitment methodology and screening process to build confidence in your services. Focus on forging a partnership rather than a single placement. With the right match and follow up, you can turn a candidate spec into an opportunity for an ongoing relationship.

Track and Refine Your Efforts

Keep records of all candidate specs sent to new clients including dates, details of the candidates, and client contact information. Follow up within a week to determine if there is any interest and see if you can schedule an exploratory call. Use client feedback to strengthen future candidate specs and your research process. Pay attention to response rates and look for any patterns in your most effective outreach. With regular tracking and refinement, candidate specs can become a lead generation machine for your recruitment firm.

Candidate specs allow you to showcase your ability to find top talent. When paired with a personalized approach and solid follow through, they are a proven way to start new business relationships and win high-quality clients. With the right strategy and refinement over time, candidate specs can drive continuous lead generation for your recruitment agency.

Setting Up Dedicated Domains for Mass Outreach

To protect your primary domain’s deliverability and reputation when conducting mass email outreach campaigns, it is advisable to set up separate domains exclusively for this purpose.

Acquiring Additional Domains

You will need to purchase additional domains through a domain registrar. Choose domain names that are generic but still relevant to your industry, e.g. ‘recruitmentagencies.com’. Ensure the domains have a professional appearance and do not contain offensive or spam-indicating terms.

Warming up New Domains

Before using new domains for mass emailing, they must be ‘warmed up’ to establish a good reputation. Send a few introductory emails from each new domain to current clients and candidates, being transparent about your purpose for the new domain. Ask them to whitelist the domain to help build its credibility. You can then gradually increase the volume of emails sent through the domain.

Separating Emailing Infrastructure

Set up separate email servers, accounts and mailing lists for your new domains to avoid linking them to your primary domain. Use different email signatures, content and ‘From’ names for each domain. Monitor the open rates, click-through rates and complaint rates for each new domain to ensure optimal performance before significantly increasing email volume.

Benefits of Dedicated Domains

Using dedicated domains for mass email outreach provides several benefits. It protects your primary domain’s reputation by avoiding a high volume of emails being linked to it. It also allows you to send more emails overall by increasing your daily sending limits. Furthermore, it enables A/B testing to determine which domain has the best open and response rates for different audiences so you can optimize your email marketing campaigns.

With the proper setup and management of dedicated domains, mass email outreach can be an effective strategy for recruitment agencies to attract new clients and candidates. Be sure to keep email content and frequency in line with anti-spam laws to build trust and get the best results.

Email Marketing Best Practices for Recruitment Agencies

Focus on Personalization

To attract both clients and candidates, personalization is key. You should customize email content based on the recipient. For candidates, use their name and mention the position they applied for. For clients, reference your previous conversations and show how you understand their hiring needs. Personalized emails have higher open and click-through rates, demonstrating your attention to detail.

Optimizing Your Subject Lines

Your subject line is the first thing recipients see and determines whether they open your email. For candidates, use an enthusiastic and encouraging subject like “You're a Great Fit for This Role!”. For clients, highlight a key capability or mention a role you have a strong candidate for, e.g. “We Have a Senior Data Scientist for You”. Subject lines with around 6 words in length containing compelling language tend to have the highest open rates.

Use CTA's to Drive Action

Add clear calls-to-action (CTAs) to your emails to prompt recipients to take action. For candidates, use CTAs like “Apply Now” or “Learn More About This Opportunity”. For clients, use CTAs such as “View Candidate Profiles” or “Schedule a Call to Discuss Your Hiring Needs”. Place your primary CTA prominently at the top of your email in a button or linked text format. This makes it easy for recipients to take their desired action.

Build Engagement with Email Sequences

Use drip campaigns and email sequences to engage candidates and clients over time. For candidates, send a series of emails highlighting different roles, companies you work with and career resources. For clients, send a sequence of emails discussing your services, recent hires you've made for other clients and industry reports. This multi-touch approach builds familiarity and trust, increasing the likelihood of a response or conversion. With regular emails over weeks or months, you can nurture relationships and drive more opportunities.

Following email marketing best practices like personalization, optimized subject lines, CTAs, and email sequencing will help your recruitment agency attract top clients and candidates. Consistently delivering value and a great experience through your email communications is key to success.

Recruitment Agency Email Marketing FAQs

What type of email content should I send to candidates?

You should send relevant content to candidates, such as job alerts for roles matching their skills and experience. Provide details on the job specifications, company overview, salary range, and application deadlines. Sending regular emails with available jobs will keep candidates engaged with your agency. You can also include career tips and advice to build rapport.

How often should I email candidates?

To avoid being marked as spam, limit emailing candidates to 2-3 times per week. While job seekers appreciate regular job alerts, sending too many emails can seem intrusive. Gauge candidate response rates to determine an optimal email frequency. If open and click rates start to drop, you may be emailing too often.

Should I use a separate domain for mass emailing?

Using a separate domain for mass email campaigns is recommended. Your primary domain risks being blacklisted if mass emails are flagged as spam. A dedicated domain allows you to send a high volume of emails without jeopardizing your main domain’s reputation. You can then “warm up” the new domain by sending a small initial batch of emails and gradually increasing the volume over time as the domain establishes credibility.

How can I make my emails more engaging?

To increase email engagement, personalize messages by using the candidate's name. Keep content concise while highlighting key details and calls to action. Use an eye-catching subject line and preview text to capture attention. Include images of the company logo, office, or team to strengthen your brand. Place important information like job listings and deadlines at the top of the email where they will be most visible. A friendly, enthusiastic tone will resonate most with candidates.

Following these best practices for recruitment agency email marketing will help you strengthen relationships with candidates, promote new job openings more effectively, and ultimately win more clients. Consistency and relevancy are key to keeping candidates engaged with your services.


As you build your email marketing strategy, remember to nurture relationships with both clients and candidates. Create relevant, valuable content to establish trust and position your agency as a thought leader. Test different email cadences to find the right balance between staying top of mind and avoiding overcommunication. Monitor metrics like open and click-through rates to continually refine your approach. With a considered, personalized email marketing plan, you can showcase your services, place strong candidates, and ultimately grow your business.

The Best Job Boards for Construction Industry Professionals

Discover the top job boards for construction professionals and employers. Compare features, pricing, and traffic insights to find the best platforms for construction jobs.
Continue reading

Electrical Engineer vs Electrician: What are the Key Differences?

In today's rapidly advancing world, the fields of electrical engineering and electrician work are more vital than ever, especially within the industrial sector. Both roles are crucial for the design, implementation, and maintenance of electrical systems that power our factories, commercial buildings, and even our homes.
Continue reading

Want to grow your recruitment business faster?

Terry Clarke, the founder of BuildStream, will schedule a 30 minute call to discuss your needs and show you our platform.
Thank you! We will get back to you soon!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Looking for a career change?

We specialize in matching great people with their dream role. It's free and only takes 2 minutes to apply.

Want to grow your recruitment business?

Our tech-enabled services help agencies win new clients, launch in new markets, grow accounts and find their ideal candidates faster.

Need to scale your recruitment?

Whether you're hiring a CFO, a full Engineering Team or a single Contracts Manager, our team of experts build your candidate pipeline so you can hire exactly who you need, fast.
  • Get interviews at interested companies within 72 hours
  • 100% discreet, we won't expose your details to anyone
  • Free for candidates, we charge companies a placement fee
  • Win new clients with outreach campaigns managed for you
  • Find hidden talent through our headhunting services
  • Fill vacancies faster with on-demand, expert resourcing support
  • Earn fees from candidate recycling campaigns
  • Map, test and enter new markets  in 30 days
Thank you! We will get back to you soon!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Terry Clarke, the founder of BuildStream, will schedule a 30 minute call to discuss your needs and show you our platform.
  • Get qualified, ready to interview candidates within 72 hours
  • Our expert sourcing team fits around your processes
  • No commission fees or long contracts
  • Fast turnaround time without compromising on quality
Thank you! We will get back to you soon!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Terry Clarke, the founder of BuildStream, will schedule a 30 minute call to discuss your needs and talk about our services.