April 11, 2024

How to Find and Partner With a Top Recruitment Agency

Table of Contents

As a hiring manager, you want to find and hire the most qualified candidates for open positions at your company. Partnering with a top recruitment agency can help streamline this process and enable you to tap into a network of pre-screened, vetted candidates. In this article, you'll learn why working with a recruitment agency provides value, how to identify and evaluate reputable firms, and key factors to discuss with recruiters to ensure an effective partnership. With the right agency match, you can enhance your talent acquisition strategy, fill roles faster with quality talent, and focus your efforts on core business priorities. Read on to optimize your hiring outcomes by finding and selecting the ideal recruitment agency partner.

Why Work With a Recruitment Agency?

Cost and Time Savings

Partnering with a recruitment agency can help reduce time and money spent on hiring. Agencies have access to a large pool of pre-screened, qualified candidates. They can match your specific job requirements to candidates with the necessary skills and experience. This targeted approach helps avoid wasting resources reviewing unqualified applicants.

Access to Top Talent

Leading recruitment agencies have connections with many high-quality candidates. They build relationships and gain knowledge about candidates’ skills, experience, work preferences, and career goals over time. This insight allows them to source candidates who may not currently be on the job market but would consider the right opportunity. Agencies can tap into this hidden talent pool to find exceptional candidates.

Expert Guidance

Recruitment agencies are staffed by professionals with extensive hiring and industry experience. They stay up-to-date with trends in hiring practices, technology, and compliance issues. Agencies can advise you on setting compensation, suggest interview techniques, and help ensure an efficient, legally-sound hiring process. Their expertise and objectivity help companies avoid costly hiring mistakes.

Peace of Mind

Working with a reputable recruitment agency provides assurance that you are taking the necessary steps to find the best available talent. Agencies handle candidate outreach, screening, and scheduling on your behalf and only put forward applicants that match your needs. With an agency handling the initial recruiting workload, you can focus your energy on interviewing top candidates and making the final hiring decision.

In summary, recruitment agencies provide access to highly-skilled candidates, hiring expertise, and overall process efficiency. Partnering with the right agency significantly improves your ability to attract and hire the best talent, allowing you to build a high-performing team.

What to Look for in a Recruitment Agency

Experience and Expertise

When selecting a recruitment agency, seek one with extensive experience in your industry and job function. Experienced recruiters will have a strong network and understanding of the key skills and experience needed for the roles you need to fill. They can source high-quality candidates faster and ensure a good skills and culture match.

A Targeted Approach

Look for an agency that takes a targeted, customized approach versus a one-size-fits-all model. They should invest time upfront to gain a deep understanding of your company culture and the specific requirements of the position. They should use this knowledge to develop a tailored recruitment strategy and rigorously screen candidates for the best fit. A targeted approach will yield better results than a generic one.

Access to Top Talent

Partner with an agency that has access to a large network of skilled candidates, including passive candidates who may not currently be on the job market.

Top agencies use advanced sourcing techniques and have connections with hard-to-reach candidates. They can tap into this network and talent pool to find candidates with the precise experience and skills you seek.

Responsiveness and Communication

Look for an agency that places a high value on responsiveness, clear communication, and collaboration. They should be readily available to address your questions or concerns, provide updates on the recruitment process, and work with you as a strategic partner. Effective communication and a spirit of teamwork will lead to a more successful recruitment experience and outcome.

In summary, partnering with a top recruitment agency can save you considerable time and money while helping you find and hire the talent you need. By looking for the right mix of experience, expertise, access, and service, you'll find an agency equipped to meet your recruitment needs.

Questions to Ask Potential Recruitment Agencies

When evaluating recruitment agencies, there are several pertinent questions you should ask to determine if they meet your needs. How long have they been in business? An agency with many years of experience will understand your industry and have a proven track record of success. They will likely have a large network of qualified candidates and long-standing relationships with top talent.

What is their area of expertise? The best agencies specialize in particular job functions, sectors, or seniority levels. Ask if they focus on positions similar to yours. An agency targeting junior roles may not have the network or expertise to fill a senior management position.

What is their process? Discuss how they source candidates, evaluate skills and cultural fit, and handle the interview and negotiation process. An organized, thorough approach that aligns with your values will lead to better outcomes.

What are their fees? Recruitment fees are often a percentage of the candidate's first-year salary. Fees typically range from 15 to 30 percent for a permanent hire. Understand all costs upfront and negotiate the best deal. Lower fees do not necessarily mean lower quality—focus on their value and results.

Can you see sample candidate resumes? Reviewing anonymized resumes of candidates in your target area will demonstrate the caliber of talent the agency can provide. Look for relevant experience, career progression, and qualifications that match your open role.

What guarantees do they offer? Typical provisions include discounted or free replacement hires if a candidate does not remain in the role for a minimum period, often 3 to 6 months. Ask about their replacement policy and any additional protections they offer. Strong agencies will stand by their hires and service.

Vetting recruitment agencies thoroughly will help you find a trusted partner that can source qualified candidates and fill your key positions. With the right questions, you can determine which agencies best fit your needs and are most likely to deliver results.

How Much Should a Recruitment Agency Charge

When partnering with a recruitment agency, their fees are an important consideration. Typically, agencies charge a percentage of the candidate’s first-year salary as a placement fee. This generally ranges from 15 to 30 percent, depending on the position and industry.

Candidate Salary

For higher-level roles with larger salaries, the percentage may be on the lower end of that range, around 15 to 20 percent. For mid-level positions, 20 to 25 percent is standard. Entry-level roles usually command 25 to 30 percent. These fees account for the time and resources required to source qualified candidates.

Additional Charges

Some agencies may charge additional fees for extra services like skills testing, background checks, or relocation assistance. Make sure you understand all potential fees upfront before making a final agency selection.

Fee Structures

There are a few common fee structures to be aware of:

  • Retainer: A flat monthly fee in exchange for a dedicated account manager and priority access to candidates. Fees are credited against eventual placements.
  • Contingency: No upfront fees. The agency only collects a percentage of the first year’s salary if they are able to fill the role. This is a lower-risk option but the agency may dedicate fewer resources to the search.
  • Hybrid: A lower retainer fee with a reduced contingency percentage. Provides dedicated support but with less upfront risk.

The fee structure is an important consideration when evaluating potential recruitment partners. Look for an agency that charges competitive yet reasonable rates, with a fee structure that suits your needs and risk tolerance. An experienced agency that charges slightly higher fees may ultimately save you money by providing higher quality candidates and a faster overall process.

In summary, plan to budget at least 15 to 30 percent of a new hire’s salary to work with a reputable recruitment agency. While fees are an investment, the right agency partner can significantly reduce your time-to-hire and ensure a successful recruitment outcome.

How to Develop a Strong Partnership With Your Chosen Agency

Once you have selected a recruitment agency to partner with, it is important to develop a collaborative working relationship. Schedule an initial meeting to discuss expectations, key performance indicators, and ways of working. Clarify the scope of work, job specifications, required skills and experience, salary range, and timeline for the roles you need to fill.

Provide Full Transparency

Share details about your company culture, values, key challenges, and strategic goals so the agency understands your priorities and environment. Be open about your hiring process, interview procedures, and requirements for candidate evaluation. Full transparency will allow the agency to source and screen candidates that closely match your needs.

Give Regular Feedback

Provide feedback on candidates submitted, including specific reasons for rejection or areas needing improvement. Work with your agency contact to refine the candidate search criteria. Offer feedback on the quality of candidates, responsiveness, and overall partnership. Regular feedback helps to strengthen the working relationship and improve results over time.

Meet Frequently

While much communication can be handled remotely via phone and email, face to face meetings are valuable for building rapport, brainstorming, and problem-solving. Aim for in-person meetings at least once a quarter to discuss progress, challenges, and new initiatives. Frequent interaction will lead to a highly productive partnership where the agency becomes an extension of your internal recruiting team.

Share Successes

Be sure to share news of successful hires placed by the agency and their impact on your organization. Success stories reinforce the value the agency provides to your business. Celebrating wins together will motivate the agency to continue sourcing outstanding candidates for your roles.

By following these best practices, you can develop a long-term strategic partnership with your recruitment agency, leading to a highly efficient hiring process and access to top talent. An investment in building a strong working relationship will yield significant rewards for your organization.

FAQs: Answering Common Recruitment Agency Questions

Will using a recruitment agency increase the cost of hiring?

While recruitment agencies do charge fees for their services, they can ultimately reduce hiring costs. By sourcing and screening candidates, they save you time and money that would otherwise be spent on advertising roles and reviewing unqualified applications. Their networks and experience also help identify candidates who are a strong match, reducing wasted effort interviewing poor fits. With an agency’s support, the hiring process becomes more targeted and efficient.

Do recruitment agencies have access to better candidates?

Yes, reputable recruitment agencies invest heavily in building networks and relationships with qualified candidates. They are able to tap into talent pools that companies may struggle to access on their own. Candidates also frequently approach agencies directly, viewing them as a path to new opportunities. Over time, agencies develop a keen sense of which candidates are most in-demand and able to fill key roles.

Will using an agency mean loss of control over the hiring process?

When partnering with an agency, you remain in full control of the hiring process and final decision making. Recruiters act as an extension of your team, getting guidance on the specific qualifications, experience, and attributes you are seeking. They then present you with a shortlist of candidates they believe meet your criteria. You interview the candidates, evaluate them, and determine who will receive an offer. At every stage, the agency takes direction from you while contributing their expertise and support. The ideal partnership is collaborative, not prescriptive.

In summary, recruitment agencies offer valuable benefits for those looking to improve their hiring outcomes in a cost-effective manner. When you find an agency that shares your priorities and values, they can become trusted partners in building an exceptional team.


As a hiring manager, partnering with the right recruitment agency can be instrumental in finding top talent for your company. While it requires an investment of time on the front end to research and select an agency that suits your needs, the long-term payoff is well worth it. With an experienced recruiter intimately familiar with your open positions, company culture, and ideal candidate profile, you gain a valuable ally in the competitive quest for talent. Approach the vetting process thoughtfully, check references diligently, and establish clear expectations upfront to set the stage for a successful, enduring partnership. The rewards of filling your ranks with qualified, engaged employees will speak for themselves. Now is the time to take the first step toward building your dream team.

The Best Job Boards for Construction Industry Professionals

Discover the top job boards for construction professionals and employers. Compare features, pricing, and traffic insights to find the best platforms for construction jobs.
Continue reading

Electrical Engineer vs Electrician: What are the Key Differences?

In today's rapidly advancing world, the fields of electrical engineering and electrician work are more vital than ever, especially within the industrial sector. Both roles are crucial for the design, implementation, and maintenance of electrical systems that power our factories, commercial buildings, and even our homes.
Continue reading

Want to grow your recruitment business faster?

Terry Clarke, the founder of BuildStream, will schedule a 30 minute call to discuss your needs and show you our platform.
Thank you! We will get back to you soon!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Looking for a career change?

We specialize in matching great people with their dream role. It's free and only takes 2 minutes to apply.

Want to grow your recruitment business?

Our tech-enabled services help agencies win new clients, launch in new markets, grow accounts and find their ideal candidates faster.

Need to scale your recruitment?

Whether you're hiring a CFO, a full Engineering Team or a single Contracts Manager, our team of experts build your candidate pipeline so you can hire exactly who you need, fast.
  • Get interviews at interested companies within 72 hours
  • 100% discreet, we won't expose your details to anyone
  • Free for candidates, we charge companies a placement fee
  • Win new clients with outreach campaigns managed for you
  • Find hidden talent through our headhunting services
  • Fill vacancies faster with on-demand, expert resourcing support
  • Earn fees from candidate recycling campaigns
  • Map, test and enter new markets  in 30 days
Thank you! We will get back to you soon!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Terry Clarke, the founder of BuildStream, will schedule a 30 minute call to discuss your needs and show you our platform.
  • Get qualified, ready to interview candidates within 72 hours
  • Our expert sourcing team fits around your processes
  • No commission fees or long contracts
  • Fast turnaround time without compromising on quality
Thank you! We will get back to you soon!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Terry Clarke, the founder of BuildStream, will schedule a 30 minute call to discuss your needs and talk about our services.